Understanding the Real Reason Why Your Customers Choose You

Have you ever wondered why your customers choose you over your competitors? You might think it’s your polished offer, superior product, or attractive pricing. But the truth might be something you haven’t fully considered.

After two decades in sales and working with hundreds of business owners, I’ve learned something essential: the real reason customers choose you often has little to do with your product—and everything to do with who they perceive you to be.

The Experiment: Asking Customers Why They Chose Me

Recently, I ran a simple but revealing exercise. I asked a few members of my LinkedIn Client Accelerator group one question:

“What made you choose me?”

No leading prompts. No conditions. I wanted raw, honest answers.

The Responses: A Revelation

The results were eye-opening—and humbling. Not a single person mentioned my detailed programme outline, my frameworks, or my content schedule.

Instead, their answers reflected who I was to them:

“Trust.”

“Your experience and credibility.”

These answers weren’t about what I delivered—but who I had become in their eyes.

It wasn’t my services they were buying. It was me.

The Real Reason: It’s Not About the Product

It’s easy to default to the idea that customers buy based on product features, deliverables, or guarantees. But more often, the decision to buy happens emotionally first—and rationally second.

When people feel they know, like, and trust you, they buy faster. And they stay longer.

Building an Audience’s Perception

Every piece of content, every message, and every interaction contributes to one thing: your audience’s perception of who you are.

They ask themselves:

• Do I believe this person understands me?
• Do I trust them?
• Do they seem credible and consistent?

If the answer is yes, then the product becomes almost secondary. They’re not comparing line items. They’re choosing a partner they feel confident in.

Try It: Shift Your Focus

Ask your customers, “Why did you choose me?”

Really listen.

You’ll start to see patterns. And most likely, you’ll find that what they’re buying is more than your offer—it’s your leadership, presence, and consistency.

If you’ve been obsessing over perfecting your pitch deck or tweaking your pricing page for the 11th time, pause. Step back. And reflect on how you’re showing up.

Who are you in the minds of your audience?

Conclusion: The Power of Perception

Your customers aren’t choosing you solely because of your product. They’re choosing you because of how they feel about you.

That’s not soft science—that’s psychology in action. And when you understand that perception shapes purchasing, you begin to prioritize trust-building, authority, and authenticity in every part of your customer journey.

Take Action: Reflect and Adjust

Ask yourself:

• Am I clear about the perception I want to create?
• Am I building trust through consistency and value?
• Am I showing up as the person my ideal buyer needs?

If not, it might be time to shift focus—from offer refinement to relationship refinement.

Share Your Insights

Have you asked your customers why they chose you? What did you learn?

Share your insights in the comments. Let’s help each other build businesses based on more than deliverables—let’s build on trust, connection, and real human value.

And if this resonated, share it with someone in your network. Sometimes, the reminder we need isn’t to work harder—it’s to be more human.

‍